Prof's wage plan won't work: Employer group

Professor's plan to narrow income gap not workable: Singapore National Employers Federation

Prof's wage plan won't work: Employer group

PROFESSOR Lim Chong Yah's radical plan to narrow the income gap is not workable, said the Singapore National Employers Federation yesterday.

Foreign investors and multinational companies do not take to shocks, and top talent may leave Singapore, warned its president Stephen Lee.

Pay increases are also not 'something you can easily switch on and off', Mr Lee added in the employer group's first comments on the proposal.

Last week, Prof Lim put forward a plan to narrow Singapore's income gap by raising the monthly wages of workers who earn below $1,500 by 50 per cent over three years, while freezing the pay of those who earn above $15,000 over the same period.

Yesterday, Mr Lee told reporters on the sidelines of the Manpower Ministry's workplan seminar that while the federation agrees with Prof Lim on the need to raise wages, it disagrees on how to do it.

Prof Lim has 'concentrated very much on the wage level', and his plan will not work 'without taking into consideration the competitiveness and the flexibility of the market', countered Mr Lee.

He argued that it is better to take a long-term view which raises wages and productivity at the same time. This will be more sustainable and 'not as radical'.

Mr Lee's comments came immediately after Minister of State for Manpower Tan Chuan-Jin also spoke about the plan. The Government will 'robustly' address the pay of low-wage workers such as cleaners, Mr Tan said in his workplan speech, but it needs 'to do so sensibly' so it does not 'adversely tilt the economy over'.

He was the first office holder from the ministry to respond to Prof Lim, although he did not refer to the professor by name in his speech. Mr Tan said: 'Let us tread carefully. Economic restructuring does not come just by raising wages alone.'

Meanwhile, Prof Lim has responded to concerns that his proposal will risk incurring job losses.

In a letter to the media on Monday, he argued that low-wage workers are already 'grossly underpaid'. Even after the 50 per cent boost over three years, their wages will still be below their productivity contributions, he added.

And as to whether low-wage workers can be helped by fiscal policies, the professor said he is worried the low-income will come to rely on government handouts for their well-being. This is why 'retraining and retraining of our workers to enhance their occupation mobility' is an integral part of the plan, he stressed.

TOH YONG CHUAN

Back to Career Resources »

Related Articles

    Singapore to see slower wage growth despite tight labour market: MAS

Singapore to see slower wage growth despite tight labour market: MAS

Wages grew at a slower pace in the second half of 2014 even though demand for workers remained high, the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) said in its bi-annual Macroeconomic Review released on Tuesday.

    Ask the right questions

Ask the right questions

Look beyond your candidates’ resumés to ensure you are getting the people you want

    Marine research lab in deep water

Marine research lab in deep water

Facility on St John's Island beset by rising costs, may slash its operations

    Improving tertiary education not just a numbers game: PM Lee

Improving tertiary education not just a numbers game: PM Lee

Unis must provide skills relevant in the future and which lead to good jobs

    S'pore banking on Asean bloc's appeal

S'pore banking on Asean bloc's appeal

Amid labour crunch, it hopes common market plan will boost region's lure

    Finding the perfect match

Finding the perfect match

Recruit the best talent for your organisation with this 10-step hiring guide